My attempt
In the first case:
HX+ adds to the OH group, giving us a carbocation. The carbocation thus formed is exceptionally stable due to back bonding. I wonder why would it go under ring expansion even though the strain is not a factor here as the ring strain in a cyclobutane ring is ~26.3 kcal/mol, and that in a cyclopropane ring is ~27.5 kcal/mol.
In the second case:
Again the HX+ adds to the OH group, giving us a tertiary carbocation with seven hyper-conjugating structures. Why would it go under ring expansion to give secondary carbocation with just two hyper-conjugating structures? I believe is based on ring strain in this case, as the ring strain in a five-membered ring is ~6.2 kcal/mol, while the ring strain in a six-membered ring is ~0.1 kcal/mol.
Source: Advanced Problems In Organic Chemistry, MS Chouhan, 11th edition; Chapter - Hydrocarbons (Alkenes); Question 180 in latest edition
No comments:
Post a Comment