Sunday, January 15, 2017

everyday chemistry - Why would breathing pure oxygen be a bad idea?


My textbook mentions that SCUBA tanks often contain a mixture of oxygen and nitrogen along with a little helium which serves as a diluent.


Now as I remember it, divers take care not to surface too quickly because it results in 'the Bends', which involves the formation of nitrogen bubbles in the blood and is potentially fatal.


If that's the case, why not use pure oxygen gas in SCUBA tanks? It seems like a good idea since it would




  • a) Enable divers to stay underwater for longer periods of time (I keep hearing that ordinary SCUBA tanks only give divers a pathetic hour or so of time underwater.




  • b) Possibly eliminate the chances of developing 'the Bends' upon surfacing. Well, it seems plausible, that is if the diver were to take a 10 minute deep-breathing session with pure oxygen to flush out whatever nitrogen's there in his lungs before hooking up a cylinder of pure oxygen and going for a dive. So if there's no gaseous nitrogen in his lungs and blood, then he wouldn't have to worry about nitrogen bubbles developing in his system.





Now those two possible advantages aren't hard to overlook, but since no one fills SCUBA tanks with pure oxygen, there must be some reason that I've overlooked, that discourages divers from filling the tanks with pure oxygen. So what is it?


Also, I hear that the oxygen cylinders used in hospitals have very high concentrations of oxygen; heck, there's one method of treatment called the Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy (HBOT) where they give patients 100% pure oxygen at elevated pressures.


Hence I doubt whether the increase in pressure associated with diving is the problem here. So I reiterate:


Why is it a bad idea for divers to breathe pure oxygen underwater?




I guess most of the recent answers have kinda missed a main point, so I'll rephrase the question:


Why is it a bad idea for divers to breathe pure oxygen underwater? If it is indeed due to pressure considerations as most sources claim, then why doesn't it seem to be a problem when patients are given 100% pure oxygen in cases like the HBOT (which is performed at elevated pressures) ?




No comments:

Post a Comment

periodic trends - Comparing radii in lithium, beryllium, magnesium, aluminium and sodium ions

Apparently the of last four, $\ce{Mg^2+}$ is closest in radius to $\ce{Li+}$. Is this true, and if so, why would a whole larger shell ($\ce{...