Saturday, August 18, 2018

grammar - Can 〜んとする mean "to pretend, to act as if"?


I'm trying to understand the meaning of the first sentence:




刀の力で日本を牛耳らんとする玲爾{れいじ}たち。その企みを見抜いた晴馬{はるま}たちは...etc.



My translation would be "Reiji and his men are not trying to control Japan with the power of katana". But in the manga where it is taken from, Reiji and his men actually ARE the bad guys trying to control Japan with the power of the katana. Since in the next sentence the author is speaking of a 企み (a plot), I thought 〜とする could mean to pretend, to act as if. Is my guess correct? Thank you for your help!



Answer




「刀{かたな}の力{ちから}で日本を牛耳{ぎゅうじ}らんとする玲爾{れいじ}​たち。その企{たくら}みを見抜{みぬ}いた​晴馬{はるま}​たちは...etc.」



Your translation of 「牛耳らんとする」 is way off, I am afraid to say. (And you have the right to say that it is mine that is way off, of course.)


Yours: "are not trying to control"


Mine: "are planning to control"




「Verb + んとする」 means "to intend to" or "to be about to"



Check here: んとする.


It is 「とする」 that you should be looking at, and not 「とする」, to begin with.


As it says in the dictionary above, 「とする」 is the colloquial form of 「とす」, which is classical Japanese. The meaning is the same for both.



"Reiji and the gang who plan to control Japan with the power of the sword. Haruma and his guys who saw through their plot...."



No comments:

Post a Comment

periodic trends - Comparing radii in lithium, beryllium, magnesium, aluminium and sodium ions

Apparently the of last four, $\ce{Mg^2+}$ is closest in radius to $\ce{Li+}$. Is this true, and if so, why would a whole larger shell ($\ce{...